Catholic and Anti-Catholic History


Read by Janet Baker

(4.5 stars; 70 reviews)

Catholic and Anti-Catholic History presents a thought-provoking exploration of how historical narratives can be shaped into tools of propaganda. Through the insights of G.K. Chesterton, James Walsh, and Hilaire Belloc, this collection examines the impact of these narratives on both truth and the human spirit.

Set against the backdrop of early 20th-century discourse, the authors delve into the complexities of religious and political history, revealing how biases can distort our understanding of the past. Their essays challenge readers to consider the implications of these distortions on contemporary society.

This work stands out for its critical examination of the intersection between faith and history, encouraging a deeper reflection on how narratives are constructed and the consequences they bear on collective memory and identity.

Chapters

Select a chapter to play

Catholic Truth in History, by Hilaire Belloc 12:44 Read by Janet Baker
Anti-Catholic History, by G.K. Chesterton 6:25 Read by Janet Baker
Twenty Historical "Don'ts," by James J. Walsh 8:27 Read by Janet Baker
Second-Hand History, by James J. Walsh 14:32 Read by Janet Baker

Reviews


(4 stars)

For those familiar with Belloc and Chesterton, they will enjoy their two contributions. Insightful to be sure, but unapologetic. The second two chapters (by other writers) are less potent and rather simply reinforce in their own way that which was already stated more clearly by the "Chesterbelloc" as their detractors at the time named them.

Four short essays, well read


(3.5 stars)

Four short theological essays, well read. Not much new to GK Chesterton readers, and not great as intro to the subject, as all essays assume some baseline knowledge on readers part. Not sure who target audience is.

Enjoyed the essays


(5 stars)

Interesting opinions in the four essays. Somewhat mystified by the notion that the middle ages were far from dark, in a sense superior to our own. The reader's voice is beautiful.

Interesting but...


(3.5 stars)

This short piece badly needs a counterpoise.

good book well read


(5 stars)

good book well read, pretty short

Anti-catholic history still exists in the minds of men, sad!


(5 stars)

excellent presentation of a fantastic book


(4.5 stars)

second to none


(5 stars)

In the slightly modified words of Treebeard, "The filth of modernism is washing away."